The Milwaukee Brewers have found themselves in a peculiar predicament with their infield defense, and the solution may lie in a surprising place: Cooper Pratt. The team's recent trade for Luis Rengifo, intended as a temporary fix, has not yielded the desired results. While Rengifo's exit velocities are in line with his career average, his launch angle has failed to materialize, resulting in a poor season. This has led to a drop in the team's overall defensive metrics, with the Brewers now ranking 18th in Outs Above Average (OAA).
Pratt, on the other hand, has been making waves in the minors. His recent hot streak, with a .301 batting average and a 143 wRC+ in the last month, has caught the attention of the team. Pratt's scouting grades indicate he is ready for the major leagues, and his fielding and arm scores are impressive. His ability to provide a defensive boost is a significant advantage, especially when considering the current state of the team's infield.
The Brewers should cut their losses with Rengifo, who is harming the team offensively and not contributing defensively. The team is already on the hook for a $1.5 million buyout in 2027, and Rengifo's contract includes bonuses for plate appearances, which the team should not continue to pay. By releasing Rengifo, the Brewers can pave the way for Pratt to play every day, which seems to be a major concern of management. Pratt's struggles at the plate are not as concerning as Rengifo's 49 OPS+.
The case for haste is compelling. The Brewers should make the move now, as the longer they wait, the less time Pratt will have to adjust to major league pitching. This is a rare move that works at two levels: it's a pivot to the future, but it's also a move that makes the team better today. The Brewers have the upcoming prospects to support this decision, and the team's current success has afforded them the time to wait and see if Rengifo turns it around.
In conclusion, the Milwaukee Brewers should cut their losses with Luis Rengifo and give Cooper Pratt the shortstop job. This move will provide a defensive boost and pave the way for Pratt to play every day, which seems to be a major concern of management. While it may be a struggle for a while at the plate, the team's current success has afforded them the time to make this move, and the potential benefits outweigh the risks.
